reviewing

name: reviewing description: Detect defects against the plan, architecture, code, and policies; classify findings without proposing improvements.

Purpose

Report defects with required severity classifications and clear impact, without remediation.

Inputs

• Artifacts under review (code, plan, architecture)
• Applicable policies and context

Severity Levels

Steps

1. Load required context: plan, architecture, policies, and artifacts.
2. Identify defects against requirements, policies, and correctness.
3. Classify each finding as P0, P1, P2, or P3.
4. Report precise locations and impacts using the required format.

Outputs

• Markdown review in the following structure; no fixes or redesigns:

## Review Summary

**Files reviewed**: X files, Y lines changed
**Overall assessment**: [APPROVE / REQUEST_CHANGES / COMMENT]

---

## Findings

### P0 - Critical

(none or list)

### P1 - High

- **[file:line]** Brief title
  - Description of issue
  - Suggested fix

### P2 - Medium

...

### P3 - Low

...

• If no issues, state what was checked, areas not covered, and residual risks.

Failure modes

• Suggesting improvements or scope changes beyond defect reporting
• Missing required P0-P3 classifications or unclear locations
• Mixing detection with remediation