---

name: openapi-schema-patterns description: Advanced OpenAPI schema patterns including allOf, naming hierarchies, and context separation

API Specification - Schema Patterns

Rules for schema design patterns and naming conventions

Pattern 1: allOf with Single $ref for Description Override

The Problem

OpenAPI ignores sibling properties when using $ref:

# ❌ WRONG - Description is LOST by OpenAPI
items:
  $ref: '#/components/schemas/UserGroup'
  description: Groups the user belongs to  # OpenAPI IGNORES THIS!

The Solution

Use allOf wrapper to preserve description:

# ✅ CORRECT - Description is preserved
items:
  allOf:
    - $ref: '#/components/schemas/UserGroup'
  description: Groups the user belongs to  # This WORKS!

When to Use

Use allOf with single $ref when you need to:

1. Add or override description on a referenced schema
2. Add additional metadata (example, deprecated, etc.)
3. Change any property that would be lost as sibling to $ref

When NOT to Use

Do NOT use allOf for actual schema composition - that's a different pattern:

# This is COMPOSITION (combining schemas) - different use case
UserInfo:
  allOf:
    - $ref: '#/components/schemas/User'
    - type: object
      properties:
        additionalField: string

---

Pattern 2: Schema Naming Hierarchy

Naming Convention

Schemas follow this hierarchy based on usage context:

Pattern	When to Use	Contains	Example
<Resource>	List operation results	Core fields for list view	User, Group, Acu
<Resource>Info	Get operation results (if different)	Full details, more than list	UserInfo, AcuInfo
<Resource>Summary	Nested references (detailed)	More than Ref, less than full	UserSummary
<Resource>Ref	Nested references (minimal)	Just id + name	OrganizationRef, ZoneSiteRef
<Context><Resource>	Resource within specific context	The Resource (2nd word) as viewed from Context (1st word)	GroupUser (User from Group), ZoneEntry (Entry from Zone)

Examples

# List result - core fields
User:
  properties:
    id: string
    status: string
    email: string
    # 10-15 fields

# Get result - full details
UserInfo:
  allOf:
    - $ref: '#/components/schemas/User'
    - type: object
      properties:
        organizationId: string
        lastLoginAt: string
        customFields: object
        # Additional 5-10 fields

# Minimal reference - nested in other schemas
OrganizationRef:
  properties:
    id: string
    name: string

# Context-specific - User (resource type) as seen from Group (context)
# Read as: "A User, from the Group's perspective"
# Used when: /groups/{groupId}/users returns this
GroupUser:
  properties:
    id: string
    name: string
    email: string
    role: string  # Group-specific field (context-specific!)

# The SECOND word (User) tells you what type of resource this is
# The FIRST word (Group) tells you from which context you're viewing it

Naming Rules

1. Base Resource (User, Group): Singular, PascalCase, used in list operations
2. Info Variant (UserInfo): Add Info suffix when get returns more fields than list
3. Ref Variant (OrganizationRef): Add Ref suffix for minimal nested references
4. Summary Variant (UserSummary): Add Summary for medium-detail nested references
5. Context Prefix (GroupUser): <Context><Resource> where Resource (2nd word) is what's returned, Context (1st word) is the perspective. So GroupUser returns a User as seen from Group context (NOT UserGroup which would return a Group!)

---

Pattern 3: Follow Original API Naming (After camelCase)

CRITICAL: We wrap external APIs - we don't design from scratch. Follow vendor API naming after normalizing to camelCase.

Field Names

# If vendor API has: user_profile_picture
# ✅ CORRECT - Convert to camelCase
userProfilePicture:
  type: string

# ❌ WRONG - Don't rename semantically
avatarUrl:  # Don't change user_profile_picture to avatarUrl
  type: string

Rule: Convert snake_case/kebab-case to camelCase, but keep the semantic name from vendor API.

Boolean Fields

# If vendor API has: is_active, has_access, can_override
# ✅ CORRECT - Keep vendor prefixes
isActive: boolean
hasAccess: boolean
canOverride: boolean

# ❌ WRONG - Don't standardize prefixes if vendor doesn't
active: boolean  # Don't remove 'is' if vendor has it

Rule: Keep vendor's boolean naming convention (is/has/can/supports) exactly as they define it.

Timestamp Fields

# If vendor API has: created_at, last_login_time, status_updated
# ✅ CORRECT - Keep vendor naming
createdAt: string
lastLoginTime: string
statusUpdated: string

# ❌ WRONG - Don't standardize suffixes
createdAt: string
lastLoginAt: string  # Don't add 'At' if vendor uses 'time'
statusUpdatedAt: string  # Don't add 'At' if vendor omits it

Rule: Keep vendor's timestamp naming pattern. If they use *_at, use *At. If they use *_time, use *Time.

Count Fields

# If vendor API has: user_count, total_entries, num_zones
# ✅ CORRECT - Keep vendor naming
userCount: integer
totalEntries: integer
numZones: integer

# ❌ WRONG - Don't standardize to *Count
userCount: integer
entryCount: integer  # Don't change totalEntries
zoneCount: integer   # Don't change numZones

Rule: Keep vendor's count field naming (count/total/num) as they define it.

Path Parameters

# If vendor API uses: /users/{user_id}
# ✅ CORRECT
paths:
  /users/{userId}:
    parameters:
      - name: userId

# If vendor API uses: /templates/{template_name}
# ✅ CORRECT
paths:
  /templates/{templateName}:
    parameters:
      - name: templateName

# If vendor API uses: /roles/{role_arn}
# ✅ CORRECT
paths:
  /roles/{roleArn}:
    parameters:
      - name: roleArn

Rule: Use whatever identifier type the vendor API uses (id/name/arn/key). Convert to camelCase but keep semantic meaning.

Security Scopes

# If vendor API defines scopes as: user:read, group:write, admin-access
# ✅ CORRECT - Match exactly (or as close as possible)
securitySchemes:
  oauth:
    flows:
      authorizationCode:
        scopes:
          user:read: Read user information
          group:write: Write group information
          admin-access: Administrative access

# ❌ WRONG - Don't normalize scope format
securitySchemes:
  oauth:
    flows:
      authorizationCode:
        scopes:
          read:users: Read user information    # Changed format!
          write:groups: Write group information # Changed format!
          access:admin: Administrative access   # Changed format!

Rule: Security scopes must match vendor API exactly so users know what to request. Don't normalize format.

---

Pattern 4: Free-Form Objects

When vendor API has truly dynamic/unknown structure objects:

# If vendor API documents a field as "dynamic configuration object"
# ✅ CORRECT - Empty object
badgeConfig:
  type: object
  description: Badge configuration for the group

# ❌ WRONG - Don't add fake structure if vendor doesn't define it
badgeConfig:
  type: object
  properties:
    color: string  # Don't make this up!
  description: Badge configuration for the group

Rule: Use empty type: object for truly dynamic fields from vendor API. Don't invent structure.

---

Summary Table

Aspect	Rule	Example
allOf single ref	Use for description override	allOf: [- $ref: Schema] + description
Schema hierarchy	Resource/Info/Summary/Ref/ContextResource	UserInfo, OrganizationRef, GroupUser
Field names	Follow vendor (camelCase)	userProfilePicture not avatarUrl
Booleans	Follow vendor prefixes	Keep is*/has*/can* as vendor defines
Timestamps	Follow vendor suffixes	Keep *At/*Time/*ed as vendor defines
Counts	Follow vendor naming	Keep *Count/total*/num* as vendor defines
Path params	Follow vendor identifier type	Use userId/userName/userArn per vendor
Security scopes	Match vendor exactly	Don't normalize scope format
Free objects	Use type: object only	When vendor docs say "dynamic"

---

Validation Questions

Before finalizing schemas, ask:

1. allOf usage: Am I using allOf with single ref just to add description? (✅) Or for actual composition? (Different pattern)
2. Schema naming: Does this follow Resource/Info/Summary/Ref/ContextResource hierarchy?
3. Field naming: Did I check the vendor API docs for the exact field name?
4. Prefixes/suffixes: Am I keeping vendor's boolean/timestamp/count conventions?
5. Path parameters: Am I using the identifier type (id/name/arn) that vendor uses?
6. Security scopes: Do these match vendor docs exactly?
7. Free objects: Did vendor docs actually say this is dynamic, or should I define structure?

---

Common Mistakes

❌ Mistake 1: Removing allOf "to simplify"

# WRONG - Loses description
items:
  $ref: '#/components/schemas/User'
  description: Active users  # OpenAPI ignores this!

❌ Mistake 2: Wrong context order

# WRONG - Should be GroupUser not UserGroup
UserGroup:  # This returns a GROUP (from user context)
  properties:
    groupId: string
    groupName: string

# CORRECT - Returns a USER (from group context)
GroupUser:  # This returns a USER (from group context)
  properties:
    userId: string
    userName: string
    role: string  # Group-specific

Remember: The SECOND word is the resource type being returned!

❌ Mistake 3: Normalizing vendor naming

# If vendor API has: last_login_time
# WRONG
lastLoginAt: string  # Changed 'time' to 'At'

❌ Mistake 4: Inventing object structure

# If vendor docs say "configuration object (dynamic)"
# WRONG
config:
  type: object
  properties:
    setting1: string  # Don't invent structure!

---

References

• Core Rules: api-spec-core-rules skill
• Critical 12 Rules: @.claude/rules/api-specification-critical-12-rules.md
• Schema Rules: api-spec-schemas skill